Blog
•
April 1, 2025
•
7 min read

Why Helium-3 for Homeland Security?

Helium-3 gas-filled proportional counters are superior in all factors of longevity, stability, and sensitivity for homeland security applications.

Marcus Chen, PhD

Principal Application Engineer · Downhole
RS-N7 compensated neutron logging tool, prepared for downhole deployment in a Permian Basin operator's lab.

The mission of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security – Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction (CWMD) Office and the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) requires neutron detection technology that will limit false alarms and protect from all threats, foreign and domestic.
 

To this day, there is not a technology in the market that is a one for one replacement for Helium-3 (³He) in all categories of longevity, stability, and sensitivity.

The impact of September 11th, 2001

The usage of Helium-3 gas spiked after the terrorist attacks on September 11th, 2001 for detectors to be used in Radiation Portal Monitors (RPMs). RPMs are used to screen people, vehicles, or other objects for the presence of illicit nuclear and radiological materials at land, sea, and air border stations, also known as ports of entry.

The Radiation Portal Monitor Program (RPMP) was successfully implemented across the United States from 2003 to 2009. Reuter-Stokes supplied over 40,000 ³He proportional counters for homeland security applications during this period.

Many of these detectors are still in use today as they were originally installed.

Assessing Helium-3 “alternatives”

The sudden reduction of the ³He stockpile led to a dramatic increase in cost and decrease in availability of the gas after September 11th, 2001. 

The U.S. and the scientific community shifted resources towards research and development of alternative technologies such as Boron-10 lined tubes, Boron-10 Straw Detectors, Lithium-6 glass, LiF/ZnS scintillators, polyvinyl toluene (PVT) plastic, and Micro-Structured Semiconductor Neutron Detectors (MSNDs).

After almost two decades of research and development, each of these technologies still fall short to meet the technical requirements that ³He proportional counters provide.

Gas conservation efforts

With over 187,000 liters of ³He processed since 2002, Reuter-Stokes understands the importance of gas conservation and we continue to take actions to ensure that ³He gas will be available for these critical applications.

Our proportional counters are designed and manufactured to have a mean time before failure (MTBF) greater than 100 years. Every detector and seal component are helium leak checked to be less than 1 X 10-9 cc/sec – air to assure that the gas will not be lost over time. This provides peace of mind and security that the detector will outlive its required use and the gas can be recycled for different purposes.

The capability to reclaim ³He gas from detectors that are no longer required for their original intent, as well as the use of government-allocated gas, allows Reuter-Stokes to continue to support the U.S. homeland security market.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vestibulum eget orci ullamcorper, euismod justo quis, ultrices mi. Donec accumsan sapien eu magna facilisis tempus. Nam varius sollicitudin justo non aliquet. Aenean aliquet lacus massa, eu consequat nunc gravida et. Proin ac elit vel ipsum posuere aliquam. Cras in tellus vitae leo molestie tristique.

What actually drives downhole detector response.

In hac habitasse platea dictumst. Nunc ultrices in erat sit amet dictum. Cras odio sapien, gravida a elementum id, placerat eget magna. Vestibulum consectetur metus eu elit pulvinar porttitor. Quisque vitae elit ligula. Sed eu rhoncus ipsum. Praesent tempus ultrices metus lacinia malesuada.

The detector parameters that actually matter for compensated logging response, in order of magnitude of impact:

The pressure-length tradeoff in practice.

Curabitur porttitor enim nunc, in imperdiet est venenatis id. Nunc molestie sapien sed leo aliquam, nec bibendum nibh dignissim. Cras eu felis vel mauris pretium volutpat. Nulla ultricies sapien at sapien venenatis lobortis. Mauris vel elementum tortor.

Sensitivity-vs-length curves for ³He at 1.0, 1.8, 2.5 and 4.0 atm — measured response from RS-P4 production data, normalized at L=300 mm.

Fusce vel viverra arcu, tempor sagittis leo. Sed ut massa tincidunt, sodales ipsum eu, rhoncus erat. Integer et nunc fermentum, commodo sapien tincidunt, rhoncus massa. Praesent scelerisque non lacus non condimentum. Nullam id dignissim augue.

“

Doubling the gas pressure delivers more sensitivity than doubling the active length — and ships in a smaller, more rugged package.

— Marcus Chen, RS Application Engineering

Sed vitae facilisis nisl. Cras sed dui aliquam, faucibus lacus eget, bibendum ex. Nullam congue justo eu ullamcorper vulputate. Curabitur vitae ligula aliquam, venenatis turpis quis, pellentesque diam. Proin faucibus ultrices vulputate.

Practical guidance for replacement spec.

When spec’ing a replacement detector for a fielded compensated neutron logging string, work the problem in this order:

Integer a volutpat massa, et pulvinar quam. Cras dolor nunc, hendrerit quis mattis eu, placerat a quam. Aenean auctor hendrerit pharetra. Pellentesque eu urna mauris. Donec eu justo sit amet eros porta ullamcorper quis eu est. Phasellus nec volutpat tellus.

More news & events

Blog

Proportional Counters for Radiation Measurement: Principles & Applications

Proportional counters are designed for the detection and measurement of ionizing radiation. They generate an electrical signal that is directly proportional to the energy deposited by the incident radiation, allowing for detection AND the characteri…
READ MORE →
Blog

Simple, Reliable Flame Monitoring – It’s Common Sense

The Reuter-Stokes approach to flame sensing originated in the core of nuclear reactors. Known for precision radiation measurements in harsh environments, the design practices that were learned in the reactor are used to sense flame presence in gas t…
READ MORE →
Blog

The Role of Flame Sensors in Gas Turbines

Infrared flame sensors are popular for industrial burner applications like boilers or furnaces. They are also sometimes used on gas turbines – but there is a drawback to this approach.
READ MORE →
Blog

Paragon x Reuter-Stokes: The New Era of Nuclear

The Paragon and Reuter-Stokes Gamma Metrics Neutron Flux Monitoring Systems (NFMS) strategic collaboration ensures continued reliability, effectively safeguarding a critical component of nuclear safety while addressing challenges such as technologic…
READ MORE →